Creating New Vegetable Beds Fast

, written by us flag

Potatoes growing in a comforter bed based on composting materials

In our article on Starting a New Vegetable Plot, there is a detailed guide to the best ways to transform any site into a fine vegetable garden. Quite a bit of digging is required, so it’s best to start with a small space and do it right. But what if you can’t? I know of three quick ways to create growing space for veggies: bag beds, bale beds, and comforter compost. I’ve tried them all, and each has its pros and cons.

Bag Beds

Blogger Chris McLaughlin calls bag gardening "the fastest gardening method in town," and it’s true. Position a bag of topsoil or tree and shrub planting mix on the ground, open the top and mix in some plant food, and you have an instant home for a tomato or lovely mix of salad greens. Roots grow through drainage holes punched in the bottoms of bag garden beds, and the bags themselves smother grass and weeds beneath them. Some people like the method so well that they use it year after year.

On the down side, some vegetables need more root space than bags provide, and the bags look tacky unless they are very well mulched. And, at the end of the season, when you collect the plastic and dispose of it, the amount of organic matter left to dig into the soil may be disappointingly small.

Peppers growing in a bag of potting compost

Bale Beds

This cool method (shown above and detailed in this article from The Oregonian) involves hollowing out bales of hay, filling them with rich potting soil or compost, and using them as instant raised beds for veggies. It’s a fun method to try, and it works especially well with shallow-rooted plants like lettuce or Asian greens.  The best thing about bale beds is what they do to the soil beneath them. In addition to smothering weeds and grass, the soil under the rotting bales becomes a haven for the earthworms known as night crawlers, which open up and enrich the subsoil with their burrows. After one season beneath a bale, you will have a new bed that’s a joy to dig.

There are imperfections. I found that the bales broke down so fast that I needed to add extra helpings of compost every week or two. By midsummer, I had reinforced the outside of the increasingly fragile bales with cardboard held in place with hemp twine. Not very pretty, but the tomatoes I grew in them didn’t complain.

Lettuce in a straw bale bed
Lettuce growing in a straw bale bed

Comforter Compost

In much the same way you might make a lasagna bed (which technically includes specific materials including peat moss), you can go about things more casually by piling compostable materials like leaves, grass clippings and pulled weeds together with thin layers of soil in a low bin (see top picture above). Like layers in a warm comforter, this type of comforter compost heap can do an amazing job as a home for potatoes, tomatoes, squash, and any type of legume.  Grass and weeds in the bed’s footprint gradually turn to compost, too. By autumn, comforter compost beds mellow into a deep bed of crumbly organic matter, ready to dig into the soil below.

Unfortunately, plants that require firm and fertile soil such as cabbage family crops or corn won’t prosper in a comforter compost bed, and maintaining even moisture levels can be a challenge. Using a soaker hose helps with this problem.

These quickie methods are no substitute for deep digging and thoughtful and consistent amending of soil with organic matter, but they are a good place to start. If you know of more ways to quickly expand growing space for veggies, please share them below.

By Barbara Pleasant

Bugs, Beneficial Insects and Plant Diseases

< All Guides

Garden Planning Apps

If you need help designing your vegetable garden, try our Vegetable Garden Planner.
Garden Planning Apps and Software

Vegetable Garden Pest Warnings

Want to Receive Alerts When Pests are Heading Your Way?

If you've seen any pests or beneficial insects in your garden in the past few days please report them to The Big Bug Hunt and help create a warning system to alert you when bugs are heading your way.

Show Comments


"Hello Barbara, I live in Tulsa, OK. and gardening in the city with a small yard can be challenging for growing lots of organic veggies. What I do is collect composting matter from neighbors and I layer this matter all over my yard in fall then in spring I just dig holes just where i am going to plant a veggie or herb. It mixes the composted matter in the soil where the plants are and in between the plant the composted matter keeps the weeds and grass out and the soil moist. It seems to work very well for me. Last year my tomatoe plants were 8' tall and produced very well. No tilling, no weeds, and less watering. "
Linda Blakeney on Saturday 20 March 2010
"An idea I've heard of but not tried, which was recommended for making an area where the ground is contaminated productive in a safe way: fill builder's bags with non- contaminated topsoil and compost, and grow plants in the bags. The soil is deep, so good for rootcrops, but I imagine most things would thrive. It might be wise to put a layer of plastic between the ground and the bag, so toxins don't get absorbed into the bag."
Elspeth Campbell on Saturday 22 May 2010

Add a Comment

Add your own thoughts on the subject of this article:
(If you have difficulty using this form, please use our Contact Form to send us your comment, along with the title of this article.)

(We won't display this on the website or use it for marketing)


(Please enter the code above to help prevent spam on this article)

By clicking 'Add Comment' you agree to our Terms and Conditions