The Art of Creating the Perfect Seed Bed

, written by Jeremy Dore gb flag

An excellent seed bed

Kitchen gardening has undergone a revolution over the past decade as garden companies, keen to exploit the resurgence of interest in healthy home-grown vegetables, have pushed the idea of ‘convenience gardening’.  This has led to some strange excesses such as the recent expose by Gardening Which magazine that found carrot plug-plants being sold at £1.09 each ($1.60) – more than a whole bunch of organic carrots would normally cost.  There is definitely a place for plug plants and convenience but sometimes the traditional methods are worth reviving and the art of creating a seedbed is one of those methods definitely worth learning.

A seedbed is a small area of the garden set aside for raising tender young plants for transplanting to other areas.  There are several advantages to this:

  • The seedlings take up less room while small, so the rest of the garden can be used for other purposes while they are developing (or can be covered with cardboard sheeting or mulch to keep down weeds).
  • The seedbed can start off plants while other parts of the garden have vegetables waiting to mature to harvest.  Once harvested, the seedlings can be transplanted, giving them a head-start for succession planting.
  • Seedbeds are less effort than starting everything in pots.  I still start early warm-season crops like tomatoes and peppers in pots so they can easily be moved indoors if a late frost occurs but for other cool-season vegetables a seedbed can be perfect.

Of course there are certain crops that don’t like being transplanted and are always sown where they will mature.  This includes most root crops such as carrots, parsnips, beetroot etc.  Brassicas (the cabbage family), on the other hand, are often recommended to be started in a seedbed and, if you are careful when transplanting them, it can even benefit them by causing a better root-system to form as the initial tap-root is broken.

The Ideal Location for Seedlings

It is tempting to locate a seedbed in a corner of the garden where nothing else grows.  However, it is better to give these young plants the best spot – if you fail to give them a good start then there will be little point in all the effort you put in to growing them later in the year as they won’t recover.  So, choose a light position, not exposed to harsh winds but not overshadowed either.  Most importantly the area should be free of perennial weeds and it’s worth avoiding areas where potatoes were grown in the previous year as leftover tubers can send up shoots that uproot seedlings.

Seedbeds can also be prepared in a greenhouse or polytunnel (known as a hoop house for our US readers) as illustrated in the pictures of my own greenhouse.  This is especially useful if you are also using the seedbed to produce earlier plantings although being at ground level the air temperature will always be lower than pots up on a greenhouse bench.

Sieving compost A garden sieve can help remove unwanted debris from compost leaving a fine textured soil

Preparing a ‘Fine Tilth’

A ‘fine tilth’ is a gardener’s term for the perfect soil structure for seeds.  The soil should be crumbly but not dusty, a bit like course breadcrumbs to handle.  This is where most of the effort comes in and how you go about preparing the perfect tilth will largely depend on the soil type you have:

  • Sandy soils will need plenty of organic matter mixed in such as sifted compost so that they can retain moisture well.
  • Heavy clay or silt soils will need breaking up and either adding fine organic matter or mixing with lighter sandy soil can help to achieve this.  You should avoid trying to prepare a tilth if the soil is still sticky due to wet weather – it needs to dry out first.  Equally, very dusty soil is bad as it will just form a hard crust after rain which is not helpful to young plants.

Most textbooks recommend using a rake to break up the soil after picking through it to remove all stones, weeds and old plant debris (which can harbour disease spores).  You certainly don’t need to dig the ground because the young seedlings will only have shallow root systems and digging just brings weed seeds to the surface.  Likewise, the soil will not need to be enriched unless you plan to also grow plants on to maturity in the bed.

My personal method for getting a perfect seedbed is a little different:

  • Pick out any weeds and debris from the surface of the bed.
  • Mix together good crumbly compost with extra soil if required in a wheelbarrow.
  • Use a garden sieve to shake this, a spade-full at a time, onto the surface of the soil to a depth of about 10cm (4 in).  A good garden sieve has a mesh of quarter inch holes and high sides so you can shake the soil through without it spilling over the sides.  Don’t put too much soil in at a time or it will take longer.
  • Finish off with a rake to smooth the soil level so that water does not run off it but soaks in evenly.  I find the back of the rake is more useful for this job than the normal prongs.  Never tread on the soil as you want it to remain light, not compacted.
Smoothing the seed bed with the back of a rake
Smoothing over the seed bed with the back of a rake prevents water running off, allowing it to soak in evenly

The final step is to make the seedbed ‘stale’ – a strange term that refers to leaving the seedbed for at least 10 days before sowing to prevent flying pests like onion fly and bean seed fly from causing problems as they are attracted to the smell of freshly disturbed soil. I usually leave the seedbed a little longer so that any remaining weed seeds can germinate and be pulled up before I sow the seeds I want.

Extra Care and Attention

A seedbed should be viewed as the garden nursery and like young children, the seedlings are going to need extra care and attention to help them thrive.  The last thing I do after the bed has been prepared is place a beer-filled trap to get rid of any slugs that are just waiting to devour young seedlings.  In fact, this year I found slugs over-wintering under my slug trap just to avoid me!  Likewise, the area should be netted if cats, birds or other wildlife are likely to disturb it since they often like to use freshly prepared soil. 

It may seem like a lot of work but there is much satisfaction to be gained from getting the perfect ground for your precious seeds.  A seedbed is a valuable addition to any productive garden and creating one is truly an art worth mastering.

Plants Related to this Article

Bugs, Beneficial Insects and Plant Diseases

< All Guides

Garden Planning Apps

If you need help designing your vegetable garden, try our Vegetable Garden Planner.
Garden Planning Apps and Software

Vegetable Garden Pest Warnings

Want to Receive Alerts When Pests are Heading Your Way?

If you've seen any pests or beneficial insects in your garden in the past few days please report them to The Big Bug Hunt and help create a warning system to alert you when bugs are heading your way.

Show Comments


"There's a lot of useful advice there, Jeremy, thank-you! You're right about giving seeds the best possible start. To reduce costs I have been using an old shopping basket as a garden sieve (although the holes are just a little too large, it still works well). I also use toilet-roll cardboard tubes as containers to grow bigger seeds in as I can transplant them out into the garden with minimal 'transplant shock'. To help with this I also use a bit of my garden soil in with the seed potting mixture, as the garden soil with contain beneficial microbes - as well as not so good microbes as you say, Jeremy. This year, I ran out of cardboard tubes and so I have been using newspaper rolled up and stapled - a neat, cheap trick I saw at the garden centre. The printing ink doesn't seem to be causing too much bother for the roots. (An advanced tip here, is that the density of roots will be improved, as roots emerging from the tube will get air-pruned and so secondary roots will develop along the main root stems, increasing surface area for nutrient-uptake.) All my tubes go into a large plastic supermarket-style bread-basket so when the tubes are watered, they are not left to stand in water as it drains easily away - wet root rot are a common cause of seedling death. Spring has Sprung!"
Kevin Hannan on Saturday 13 March 2010
"I NEED QUICK HELP, I know that i have to start with greeting but my stress becomes first. my adviser orders me to make a presentation on "which beding system is best for carrot production" . i can't get any thing. so i neen your help in 10 days. i'm Bsc student in Amu."
mohammed ibrahim on Thursday 6 December 2012
"A small plot of 3 m2 (3m × 1m) in area was taken from a selected land with the help of a measuring tape keeping 50-60 cm gap from one bed to another."
tanvir on Monday 26 October 2015

Add a Comment

Add your own thoughts on the subject of this article:
(If you have difficulty using this form, please use our Contact Form to send us your comment, along with the title of this article.)

(We won't display this on the website or use it for marketing)


(Please enter the code above to help prevent spam on this article)

By clicking 'Add Comment' you agree to our Terms and Conditions